Could the Compassion We Show to Animals Also Be Shown to Humans?
The tendency for some people to prioritize helping animals over aiding humans in need can be deeply rooted in a mix of emotional, cultural, and psychological factors. Many individuals feel a strong emotional connection to animals, often perceiving them as innocent and vulnerable beings. This perception fosters a protective instinct that can be more pronounced than the one directed toward fellow humans, especially those who are homeless or at risk.
There’s also a societal narrative that paints animals as pure and deserving of compassion, while the complex circumstances surrounding human hardship can lead to feelings of suspicion or judgment. This sentiment is further exacerbated by media portrayals and political rhetoric that frame poverty and homelessness as a personal failure rather than a systemic issue.
From a young age, children absorb messages about “us versus them.” Politicians and social narratives often amplify fears and stereotypes about marginalized groups, depicting them as threats or as people who will take advantage of charity. This creates a distancing effect that hampers empathy and fosters a sense of fear—essentially leading individuals to feel safer and more justified in helping animals, who appear untainted by societal flaws.
Moreover, supporting animal welfare often feels like a straightforward act of kindness, free from the moral complexities associated with helping humans in difficult situations. It can feel simpler to save a stray dog than to navigate the complexities of human relationships, addiction, mental health, and social justice issues. That said, this choice reflects a troubling dichotomy: an innate desire to love and care for one another is often eclipsed by fear and societal conditioning that fosters division rather than unity.
At the core of this is a fundamental conflict between love and fear. The human experience is characterized by the capacity for deep empathy and connection, yet external narratives can distort that innate sense of community. Reframing how we view and address social issues may help bridge this divide, allowing love to prevail over fear, and promoting a more holistic approach to compassion that encompasses both humans and animals. After all, the essence of humanity lies in our ability to care for one another, regardless of species.
Robin Campbell
Manna Homeless Society
Donations can be made by e-transfer to:
Or cheques can be sent to:
Manna Homeless Society
P.O. Box 389
Errington BC VOR 1VO
